Questions of ethnic heritage began on day one of Sonia Sotomayor\u2019s nomination, as media outlets remarked on the first-ever nomination and both political parties debated the implications of Obama\u2019s choice.<\/p>\n\n
And throughout the nomination process, Hispanics remained closely tied to the coverage. About half (48%) of stories about Sonia Sotomayor included a significant mention of her Hispanic heritage. <\/p>\n\n
Most of the Hispanic references in stories about the nomination, indeed, were aimed directly at the nominee and the role that her ethnic heritage could play in the confirmation process. <\/p>\n\n
The first rush of stories following the May 26 announcement nearly all remarked on the historic potential for the first-ever Hispanic Supreme Court justice. NBC Nightly News Anchor Brian Williams, for example, opened the May 26 newscast with, \u201cPresident Obama makes history by choosing Sonia Sotomayor for the United States Supreme Court. Raised in New York City public housing, will she be confirmed as the first Hispanic woman on the high court?\u201d<\/p>\n\n
Brett Baier of the Fox News Special Report also led off his May 26 broadcast by commenting on the historic significance of Obama\u2019s choice: \u201cThe nation\u2019s first African-American president today nominated the person who could become the nation\u2019s first Hispanic Supreme Court Justice and only the third woman to serve on the high court.\u201d <\/p>\n\n
Spokane\u2019s Spokesman Review likewise remarked that Sotomayor \u201cwould be the first Hispanic justice on the high court\u201d but also sought out the opinion of the Hispanic community. The Latino advocacy group Hispanics for a Fair Judiciary praised Obama and Sotomayor, telling the Spokesman Review, \u201cThe president deserves praise for working to make a Hispanic voice heard in the exclusive chambers of our nation\u2019s highest court.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
By the next day, much of the media had concluded that Sotomayor\u2019s race would be a stumbling block for Republicans opposed to her confirmation. As a May 27 Associated Press article in the Meadville Tribune summarized, \u201cRepublicans, at sea as a party and having lost ground with Hispanic voters, the fastest-growing segment of the population, will have a hard time defeating the woman who would be the first Hispanic justice. And the inevitable partisan fights over Sotomayor’s nomination hold heavy risks for a party striving to draw beyond its mostly white, Southern and conservative base.\u201d <\/p>\n\n
The notion that race was too much a part of Sotomayor\u2019s legal thinking became a major talking point and dividing line in the media debate. <\/p>\n\n
On the May 26 edition of Hardball, for example, Pat Buchanan said that he thought Sotomayor\u2019s statements about her race and gender should disqualify her. \u201cI\u2019m saying that she herself says that her gender and her ethnicity will influence her decision, and that would be for me a disqualification for the Supreme Court. She is an affirmative action pick… Clearly the President was down to four choices, all of them women, and he picked the Hispanic.\u201d <\/p>\n\n
Yet almost all of these were matched by defenses by Democrats or liberal commentators backing her nomination, such as the answer by Senator Charles Schumer (D-NY), responding to such claims in a May 27 interview on the Today Show: \u201cIt\u2019s not fair at all. She is just top-notch legally\u2026and her record on the bench is outstanding.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
While the high-profile commotion over Sotomayor\u2019s nomination took place in the newspapers and airwaves, a quieter but nevertheless impassioned debate was taking place online about whether Sotomayor was actually the first Hispanic on the court, or if one should count former Justice Benjamin Cardozo, who was of Portuguese descent. At the heart of this discussion was the question of the meaning of \u201cHispanic.\u201d <\/p>\n\n
On the Wall Street Journal\u2019s law blog, Harvard Law professor Andrew Kaufman gave a decidedly undecided answer: \u201cI have had many long conversations with a variety of newspaper people about whether Cardozo was the first whatever-name-you-want-to-use. It\u2019s all in the context.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
Adding to the semantic discussion was the Los Angeles Times, which ran a May 31 article asking this very question, entitled \u201cWould Sotomayor really be the first Supreme Court Latino?\u201d The paper was then forced to run a correction on June 2, as an editor had changed the reporter\u2019s references from \u201cHispanics\u201d to \u201cLatinos.\u201d The correction stated, \u201cThe article referred to a semantic debate over whether Sotomayor was the first Hispanic to be nominated to the Supreme Court and not Cardozo. The article should have said that advocacy groups praised Sotomayor, a New York-born Puerto Rican, as the first Hispanic, which prompted political opponents to argue that Cardozo’s Portuguese heritage qualified him as the first Hispanic.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
(A May 2009 report released by the Pew Hispanic Center explains that the question can be boiled down to who is creating the definitions, distinguishing between the Census Bureau\u2019s approach to defining a person as Hispanic \u201cYou are if you say so\u201d and the more concrete OMB definition, which distinguishes between countries of origin in determining ethnicity.) Read more about this subject in the Pew Hispanic Center\u2019s May report on the topic.<\/p>\n\n
After the initial wave of excitement created by her nomination, coverage dropped gradually, only to see another large spike in July, during Sotomayor\u2019s confirmation hearings. Once again, her Hispanic heritage featured heavily in the discussion as senators questioned Sotomayor in particular about remarks she made eight years ago about her Hispanic heritage. In a 2001 address to the University of California at Berkeley School of Law, Judge Sotomayor stated, \u201cI would hope that a wise Latina woman with the richness of her experiences would more often than not reach a better conclusion than a white male who hasn’t lived that life.\u201d <\/p>\n\n
These comments, along with Sotomayor\u2019s decision on a case about racial profiling at a fire department in Connecticut, brought about allegations that Sonia Sotomayor herself was a racist. Much of this keyed on her speech at Berkeley.<\/p>\n\n
Indeed, in a separate analysis run for PEJ by a team of academics from Cornell and Stanford of the most repeated concepts in the media during this period, the term \u201cwise Latina\u201d ranked fourth out of all the concepts captured. Through a new technology-based media analysis system called \u201cMeme-tracker,\u201d the team examines a much wider swath of media\u20141.6 million media sites and blogs\u2014and can identify and track the most frequently quoted phrases and concepts resonating throughout the media. Through a process of identifying the phrases and then searching for the words around them and similar ideas that might have come from other people, the researchers identify what they call \u201cmemes,\u201d a word derived from the Greek word mimema, that in the internet age has been adopted to mean cultural idea. They found that from February 1 through July 3, the quote \u201cwise Latina\u201d was repeated more than 2,500 times, coming in behind only three other phrases, all of which came from President Obama\u2019s public remarks. <\/p>\n\n
This politicization of race caused frustration among some conservative news personalities. On The O\u2019Reilly Factor on July 15, Fox commentator Monica Crowley voiced a common opinion among some pundits, as she wondered if \u201cwhite guilt\u201d contributed to Sotomayor\u2019s nomination and popularity: \u201cGiven the politically correct multicultural environment in America today,\u201d said Crowley, \u201cthe most radical thing President Obama could have done is nominate a white guy to the court.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
One aspect of the coverage of the Sotomayor nomination was the propensity of the press to make comparisons in order to more easily gauge the political climate at the unprecedented prospect of a Latina on the Supreme Court. Outlets both liberal and conservative searched for reference points to other politically successful women and minorities in their debates and predictions surrounding Sotomayor\u2019s nomination and confirmation.<\/p>\n\n
On O\u2019Reilly, for instance, Crowley compared Sotomayor to people she considered to be more conservative and to have sustained a tougher beating in the political arena, such as failed Bush Supreme Court nominee Harriet Miers, former vice presidential nominee Sarah Palin, former justice Sandra Day O\u2019Connor, and sitting Justice Clarence Thomas.<\/p>\n\n
But some more liberal outlets used this same tactic to make opposite points about the prospects for ethnic minorities, as well as women, in political appointments. Keith Olbermann often expressed anger at what he considered to be unfair right-wing charges of \u201creverse racism\u201d on Sotomayor. On a May 27 episode of Countdown, Olbermann made his own comparison of Sotomayor to former Attorney General Alberto Gonzales, complaining that Democrats during Gonzales\u2019 confirmation feared charges of racism themselves: \u201cFour years ago, we were being told that Alberto Gonzales had to be confirmed as attorney general for Mr. Bush and if you questioned what were truly sketchy credentials, you were an anti-Hispanic racist.\u201d<\/p>\n\n
For all the conversation about race and, to a lesser extent, gender, though, the likelihood of Sotomayor\u2019s confirmation itself was never seriously in question. This, along with her controversial comments about ethnicity and the law, may have helped create an atmosphere in which race became a central part of the debate. <\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"
Questions of ethnic heritage began on day one of Sonia Sotomayor\u2019s nomination, as media outlets remarked on the first-ever nomination and both political parties debated the implications of Obama\u2019s choice. And throughout the nomination process, Hispanics remained closely tied to the coverage. About half (48%) of stories about Sonia Sotomayor included a significant mention of […]<\/p>\n","protected":false},"author":139,"featured_media":0,"comment_status":"open","ping_status":"open","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"sub_headline":null,"sub_title":"","_prc_public_revisions":[],"_ppp_expiration_hours":0,"_ppp_enabled":false,"ai_generated_summary":"","_jetpack_newsletter_access":"","_jetpack_dont_email_post_to_subs":false,"_jetpack_newsletter_tier_id":0,"_jetpack_memberships_contains_paywalled_content":false,"apple_news_api_id":"","apple_news_api_revision":"","apple_news_api_created_at":"","apple_news_api_modified_at":"","apple_news_api_share_url":"","apple_news_api_pending":"","apple_news_is_preview":false,"apple_news_is_hidden":false,"relatedPosts":[],"reportMaterials":[],"multiSectionReport":[],"package_parts__enabled":false,"package_parts":[],"datacite_doi":"","datacite_doi_citation":"","_prc_seo_qr_attachment_id":0,"spoken_article_player_enabled":true,"displayBylines":true,"footnotes":"","prc_watchers":[],"_prc_fork_parent":0,"_prc_fork_status":"","_prc_active_fork":0,"jetpack_post_was_ever_published":false},"categories":[],"tags":[],"bylines":[921],"collection":[],"datasets":[],"level_of_effort":[],"primary_audience":[],"information_type":[],"_post_visibility":[],"formats":[458],"_fund_pool":[],"languages":[],"regions-countries":[],"research-teams":[527],"workflow-status":[],"class_list":["post-90039","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","hentry","bylines-benjamin-wormald","formats-report","research-teams-journalism"],"label":false,"post_parent":90003,"word_count":1487,"canonical_url":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/sonia-sotomayor\/","art_direction":false,"_embeds":[],"watchers":[],"table_of_contents":[{"id":90003,"title":"Hispanics in the News","slug":"hispanics-news","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/hispanics-news\/","is_active":false},{"id":90010,"title":"Overall Coverage of Hispanics in the News","slug":"overall-coverage-hispanics-news","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/overall-coverage-hispanics-news\/","is_active":false},{"id":90017,"title":"Biggest Storylines","slug":"biggest-storylines","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/biggest-storylines\/","is_active":false},{"id":90023,"title":"Broad Topics","slug":"broad-topics","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/broad-topics\/","is_active":false},{"id":90033,"title":"The Hispanic Experience","slug":"hispanic-experience","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/hispanic-experience\/","is_active":false},{"id":90039,"title":"Sonia Sotomayor","slug":"sonia-sotomayor","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/sonia-sotomayor\/","is_active":true},{"id":90045,"title":"Mexican Drug War","slug":"mexican-drug-war","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/mexican-drug-war\/","is_active":false},{"id":90049,"title":"Swine Flu\/H1N1","slug":"swine-fluh1n1","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/swine-fluh1n1\/","is_active":false},{"id":90055,"title":"Immigration and Hispanics","slug":"immigration-and-hispanics","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/immigration-and-hispanics\/","is_active":false},{"id":90063,"title":"Lead Newsmakers","slug":"lead-newsmakers","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/lead-newsmakers\/","is_active":false},{"id":90072,"title":"Differences by Media Sector","slug":"differences-media-sector","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/differences-media-sector\/","is_active":false},{"id":90078,"title":"Methodology","slug":"methodology-3-6","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/methodology-3-6\/","is_active":false},{"id":89931,"title":"Topline","slug":"topline-2","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/topline-2\/","is_active":false}],"report_materials":"","report_pagination":{"current_post":{"id":90039,"title":"Sonia Sotomayor","slug":"sonia-sotomayor","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/sonia-sotomayor\/","is_active":true,"page_num":6},"next_post":{"id":90045,"title":"Mexican Drug War","slug":"mexican-drug-war","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/mexican-drug-war\/","is_active":false,"page_num":7},"previous_post":{"id":90033,"title":"The Hispanic Experience","slug":"hispanic-experience","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/hispanic-experience\/","is_active":false,"page_num":5},"pagination_items":[{"id":90003,"title":"Hispanics in the News","slug":"hispanics-news","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/hispanics-news\/","is_active":false,"page_num":1},{"id":90010,"title":"Overall Coverage of Hispanics in the News","slug":"overall-coverage-hispanics-news","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/overall-coverage-hispanics-news\/","is_active":false,"page_num":2},{"id":90017,"title":"Biggest Storylines","slug":"biggest-storylines","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/biggest-storylines\/","is_active":false,"page_num":3},{"id":90023,"title":"Broad Topics","slug":"broad-topics","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/broad-topics\/","is_active":false,"page_num":4},{"id":90033,"title":"The Hispanic Experience","slug":"hispanic-experience","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/hispanic-experience\/","is_active":false,"page_num":5},{"id":90039,"title":"Sonia Sotomayor","slug":"sonia-sotomayor","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/sonia-sotomayor\/","is_active":true,"page_num":6},{"id":90045,"title":"Mexican Drug War","slug":"mexican-drug-war","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/mexican-drug-war\/","is_active":false,"page_num":7},{"id":90049,"title":"Swine Flu\/H1N1","slug":"swine-fluh1n1","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/swine-fluh1n1\/","is_active":false,"page_num":8},{"id":90055,"title":"Immigration and Hispanics","slug":"immigration-and-hispanics","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/immigration-and-hispanics\/","is_active":false,"page_num":9},{"id":90063,"title":"Lead Newsmakers","slug":"lead-newsmakers","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/lead-newsmakers\/","is_active":false,"page_num":10},{"id":90072,"title":"Differences by Media Sector","slug":"differences-media-sector","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/differences-media-sector\/","is_active":false,"page_num":11},{"id":90078,"title":"Methodology","slug":"methodology-3-6","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/methodology-3-6\/","is_active":false,"page_num":12},{"id":89931,"title":"Topline","slug":"topline-2","link":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/journalism\/2009\/12\/07\/topline-2\/","is_active":false,"page_num":13}]},"parent_info":{"parent_title":"Hispanics in the News","parent_id":90003},"materialsOrdered":[],"chaptersOrdered":[],"partsOrdered":[],"partsEnabled":false,"datacite_doi":"","prc_seo_data":{"title":"Sonia Sotomayor","description":"Questions of ethnic heritage began on day one of Sonia Sotomayor\u2019s nomination, as media outlets remarked on the first-ever nomination and both political parties debated the implications of Obama\u2019s choice.…","og_title":"Sonia Sotomayor","og_description":"","schema_type":"Article","noindex":false,"canonical_url":"","primary_terms":[],"custom_schema":[],"og_image":0,"indexnow_submitted_at":null,"gsc_index_status":null},"prepublish_checks":{"prc-image-alt-text":{"status":"complete","message":"No image blocks in content.","data":null},"prc-about-this-research":{"status":"incomplete","message":"Add an \"About this research\" details block.","data":null},"prc-paragraph-count":{"status":"complete","message":"Found 22 paragraphs.","data":{"count":22}},"prc-internal-link":{"status":"incomplete","message":"Add at least one internal link.","data":{"count":0}}},"jetpack_featured_media_url":"","jetpack_sharing_enabled":true,"relatedPostsOrdered":[],"bylinesOrdered":[{"key":"7612de71-f3d7-4d04-bb5b-bda65dd47479","termId":921}],"acknowledgementsOrdered":[],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/90039","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/139"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=90039"}],"version-history":[{"count":2,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/90039\/revisions"}],"predecessor-version":[{"id":135510,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/90039\/revisions\/135510"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=90039"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"bylines","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/bylines?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"collection","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/collection?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"datasets","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/datasets?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"level_of_effort","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/level_of_effort?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"primary_audience","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/primary_audience?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"information_type","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/information_type?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"_post_visibility","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/_post_visibility?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"formats","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/formats?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"_fund_pool","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/_fund_pool?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"languages","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/languages?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"regions-countries","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/regions-countries?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"research-teams","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/research-teams?post=90039"},{"taxonomy":"workflow-status","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/alpha.pewresearch.org\/pewresearch-org\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/workflow-status?post=90039"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}